Florida foreclosure surplus
What Happens When You Sign With Two Foreclosure Surplus Companies in Florida?
After a foreclosure sale, the phone calls start fast. If your home sold for more than the judgment, there may be surplus money sitting in the court registry with your name on it, and recovery companies know it. They are polite, they move quickly, and their paperwork sounds simple.
What happens if you sign with one company, and then, weeks later, sign with a second one too?
It happens more often than you would think. In one recent Florida condo foreclosure, the owners lived out of state and never appeared in the case. The first company signed both spouses about three months before the sale. The second company signed just the husband about nine weeks later. After the sale, both companies filed motions asking the court to pay the same surplus, about $47,000, to them. The homeowners association that foreclosed filed its own motion the same week, asking for roughly $6,500 more in assessments that had built up after the judgment.
Three claims. One pot of money. And the owners, the people the money actually belongs to, were not in the room for any of it.
Why the first signing usually matters most
Florida law starts with a simple idea: the owner of record when the foreclosure began is presumed to be the person entitled to the surplus. A recovery company steps into the owner's shoes only through a valid assignment. When two assignments cover the same money, courts look hard at who signed first, and whether the signing was complete.
Complete matters. If a property has two owners, an assignment from only one of them reaches only that person's interest. A company holding signatures from both spouses is in a much stronger position than a company holding one, no matter how quickly the second company files its motion. Filing first in court does not fix signing second on paper.
The clauses nobody reads out loud
The fine print in these agreements is where the real fight lives. In that same case, the two contracts handled double-signing in opposite ways:
- The first company's agreement made the owners promise they had not assigned their rights to anyone else, and pre-agreed that if a dispute over assignments ever arose, all of the surplus would stay in the court registry until the dispute was resolved.
- The second company's agreement said that if the owner had already assigned the rights to another company before signing, the second company could claim $6,000 in liquidated damages from the surplus.
Read that again. The penalty clauses do not just bind the companies. They come out of the owner's money. A moment of confusion on the phone, or signing a second set of papers because the first company went quiet, can shrink what the family ultimately receives.
Fees that look the same rarely are
Both companies in that case charged a headline fee of 12 percent, which is the most common number in Florida. The difference was what rode on top of it. One company's 12 percent covered its costs. The other company's agreement took 12 percent and then charged its attorney's fees and costs out of the owner's share on top of that. Same headline, different check at the end.
Before you sign anything, ask one plain question: is your fee all-in, yes or no? Get the answer in the agreement itself, in writing, as a single number.
The association may not be finished either
Surplus fights are not only between recovery companies. In a condo or HOA foreclosure, the final judgment often secures assessments that keep accruing between the judgment and the sale. After the sale, the association can come back for that extra amount before the owner's share is calculated. On a surplus of about $47,000, that supplemental claim was roughly $6,500, about 14 percent of the fund, gone before any recovery fee was even discussed. The number a company quotes you on the phone is usually the gross figure. The number that matters is what is left after everyone ahead of you is paid.
How to protect yourself
- Sign with one company only, and tell any other caller, in writing, that you have already signed.
- Make sure every owner on the deed signs, or understands why they are not signing.
- Read the fee clause and the double-assignment clause before you sign, not after.
- Remember you can also claim the surplus yourself, or hire your own attorney at a fee you negotiate. In several Florida cases we have studied, owners who claimed directly kept everything.
- If you have already signed twice, do not panic and do not sign a third time. Tell both companies about each other, in writing, and let the court sort out entitlement. The money stays in the registry while they argue; it does not disappear.
The surplus is your money. The paperwork decides how much of it you keep.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Every case is different; consult a licensed Florida attorney about your specific situation.