All articles

Florida tax deed surplus

You Signed Away Your Tax Sale Surplus Twice. Who Actually Gets Paid in Florida?

When a property sells at a Florida tax deed sale for more than the taxes owed, the extra money does not disappear. The clerk of court holds it as surplus, and the former owner can claim it. That is also when recovery companies come calling, often within days of the sale, offering to handle the claim for a percentage of the money.

Most owners sign once. Occasionally, an owner signs twice, with two different companies, months apart. A recent Polk County case shows exactly how that plays out, and the lessons are worth knowing before you sign anything.

What happened

In that case, the sale left a little under $109,000 sitting with the clerk. Six days after the sale, the person in charge of the company that had owned the land signed an assignment giving one recovery company all of his interest in the surplus. That company filed its claim with the clerk right away.

About seven months later, he signed again, this time with a second company. That second agreement said he would keep most of the money and the company would take 29 percent of what was recovered, after expenses, plus its costs. It also stated, in writing, that he had not assigned his interest to anyone else. That statement was not true. The first assignment was already seven months old.

The second company filed its own claim for the full amount, payable to itself. Then the clerk did what clerks do when two parties claim the same money: the clerk filed an interpleader lawsuit and let a judge decide.

The part nobody tells you

Here is the detail that decided everything. Filing a claim form with the clerk is only the first step. Once the clerk interpleads the money, the fight moves into a courtroom, and each claimant has to answer the lawsuit and prove its claim there.

Only the first company did that. It answered, filed a motion, and showed up at the hearing. The second company never answered at all. Neither did the former owner or anyone else with a possible interest. The judge awarded 100 percent of the remaining money, after the clerk's attorney fees of about $2,700 were taken off the top, to the first company's lawyer's trust account. The second company received nothing, despite holding a signed agreement.

Three lessons if a company asks you to sign

First, the first signature usually controls. If you have already assigned your surplus to one company, signing with a second company does not cancel the first deal. It creates a dispute, delays your money, and can leave you caught between two contracts.

Second, read what the paper says about the fee, and notice what it does not say. In this case, the winning company's filed assignment transferred 100 percent of the owner's interest for ten dollars and said the real fee arrangement was in a separate agreement that was never filed with the court. The owner, and anyone reading the public record, could not tell from the court file what percentage that company actually kept. A trustworthy agreement states one clear fee, in the agreement itself, before you sign.

Third, compare the price. The second company in this case charged 29 percent, near the top of what we see in Florida files. Some companies charge far less. The percentage is negotiable, and it should be weighed against what the company actually does, including whether it will appear in court if the clerk interpleads the money, because that appearance is what got the first company paid.

What to do if you are holding two agreements

Do not sign a second agreement hoping it replaces the first. Tell each company about the other, in writing. Ask the clerk's office what claims are already on file for your sale; the claim file is the ground truth, not a salesperson's representation. And if a lawsuit is filed over the money, take the deadlines seriously, because a claimant who never answers can lose everything, and an owner who never appears can watch the whole fund go to someone else.

Surplus money is your money. The companies competing for it are selling speed, paperwork, and follow-through. Pay for those things at a stated, reasonable price, in one agreement, and make sure the company you choose will still be there when a judge asks who showed up.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Every case is different; consult a licensed Florida attorney about your specific situation.