Florida tax deed surplus
You Signed Your Tax Sale Surplus Twice in Eight Days. Now Three People Claim It in Florida.
When a Florida property sells at a tax deed sale for more than the taxes owed, the extra money, called surplus, is held by the county clerk until the rightful owners claim it. That money can sit quietly for months. It can also attract a crowd.
In one recent Florida case, an heir signed a recovery agreement with one company four days after the sale. Eight days later, he signed with a second company. Months after that, his own probate lawyer filed a third claim for the entire fund. The clerk did the only sensible thing: filed an interpleader lawsuit and asked the court to sort it out. The money is still waiting while everyone explains their paper.
If you have inherited a property that was lost to a tax sale, this is the pattern to understand before you sign anything.
Signing twice does not double your money
An assignment gives the company your right to claim the surplus, in exchange for its work recovering it. Signing a second assignment does not cancel the first one by magic. It creates a fight. Courts generally look at who signed first, whether the signer actually owned the share they assigned, and what each agreement says. The loser of that fight usually collects nothing, after months of delay for everyone.
There is a harder problem underneath this case. The property had been owned in equal halves by two relatives, both deceased. The heir who signed twice appears to have inherited only one half. The other half belongs to the other owner's children, who have never filed a claim at all. A person can only assign what they own, so a contract covering 100 percent of the fund, signed by someone who owns 50 percent, is worth half its face at best.
Read the fee, because the range is enormous
The two agreements in this case show how wide the pricing runs. One company charged a flat percentage of about a third of the surplus, plus reimbursement of its fees and costs out of the owner's share. The other used a sliding scale: 50 percent on the first bracket of money, stepping down as the amount grows, which worked out to 35 percent on this fund. On a fund of about $46,000, those two offers differ from each other, and both differ enormously from a low, single fee stated plainly in the agreement.
Before you sign, ask three questions. What is the fee in dollars, not just percent? Is anything charged on top of the percentage, such as attorney's fees or costs taken from your share? And is the fee printed in the agreement itself, where a judge can see it, rather than left to a separate document?
Watch the number the clerk is actually holding
Surplus figures change on paper. In this same case, the fund was described at about $48,000 in one company's disclosure, about $47,500 in the clerk's official notice, and about $46,000 when the clerk filed the interpleader, with no itemized explanation for the differences in the filings. Some deductions are normal, but you should always quote and plan from the clerk's current figure, and you are entitled to ask what was deducted and why.
A safer order of operations
First, confirm the surplus exists and get the clerk's current amount. Second, confirm what share of it is legally yours, especially when the property passed through one or more estates. Third, compare any company's fee in writing against doing the claim with your own lawyer. Fourth, sign with one company only, and keep a copy of everything. If two companies both claim to represent you, tell the clerk in writing and get independent advice before anyone is paid.
The money held by the clerk is yours by law, not a prize for whoever reaches you first. A few days spent checking shares and fees can be worth thousands of dollars.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Every case is different; consult a licensed Florida attorney about your specific situation.