Florida tax deed surplus
Two Families Claimed the Same Tax Sale Money in Florida. The Judge Asked Two Questions First.
When a property sells at a Florida tax deed sale for more than the taxes owed, the extra money does not disappear. The clerk holds it, and the people entitled to it can claim it. When more than one side claims the same fund, the clerk can file what is called an interpleader, which hands the money to the court and lets a judge decide who gets paid.
In one recent Polk County case, the tax sale left a surplus of more than $96,000, and the claims pointed in opposite directions. Understanding why the judge slowed the case down, and what finally unlocked it, can save your own claim months of delay.
Two owners, two very different stories
The home had been bought by two people as joint tenants with the right of survivorship. That phrase matters. With survivorship, when one owner dies, the other owner ordinarily takes the whole property automatically.
One of the owners later died without a will. Her children and other relatives, working through the administrator of her estate in another state, claimed half of the surplus for her side of the family. The surviving owner claimed all of it. His argument was simple: survivorship made him the sole owner the moment she died, so every dollar of the surplus was his.
Both arguments were plausible. Neither was ever actually decided by the court, because the two sides eventually agreed to split the money evenly, half to the estate side and half to the surviving owner. That kind of compromise is common when both sides have a real legal theory and litigation would cost more than it could win.
Two questions the judge would not skip
Before signing the settlement, the judge stopped and asked for two documents.
First, one of the claim forms described a man as the deceased owner's surviving spouse. He had not signed the settlement, and nothing in the file proved he had no claim. If he really was a surviving spouse, part of the money might belong to him or his estate. The parties went back and produced the divorce judgment from before her death. He was an ex-husband, not a surviving spouse, and he received nothing. One document answered the question completely.
Second, the surviving owner could not appear for himself, so his daughter had signed the settlement using a power of attorney. The judge asked for the actual power of attorney to be filed, so the court could confirm she had legal authority to bind him. Once that document was on file, the court approved the settlement and ordered the money paid out.
What the recovery companies charged
Each side had hired a surplus recovery company, and each company charged 20 percent of the share it worked on. On the estate side, the company took the same dollar amount as each individual family member received. On the surviving owner's side, the company also absorbed his lawyer's fee out of its own 20 percent, so his 80 percent stayed whole.
Two lessons hide in those numbers. Fees in contested cases run higher than in simple ones, because the work is heavier. And a settlement that has to divide real dollars among real people tends to put everyone's fee in writing, where a quiet, uncontested claim may never show the price at all. Before you sign with any company, ask for the fee in writing, in the agreement itself, and ask whether costs or lawyer fees come out of your share or theirs.
What to do before you claim
If you believe tax sale or foreclosure surplus money is waiting for you, gather the paper a judge will eventually want. Bring proof of how the property was titled. Bring death certificates, wills, divorce judgments, and any power of attorney. A claim that looks complete on its face can still stall for months over one missing document about one person who is not even in the room.
And if someone describes a relative's status in a claim form, check it against the records. In this case, two words, surviving spouse, nearly redirected part of a $96,000 fund to a man who had been divorced from the owner before she died.
The money was eventually paid in full, split evenly between the two sides, a little over a year after the court case began. It could have moved faster if the two key documents had been in the file from the start.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Every case is different; consult a licensed Florida attorney about your specific situation.